Oatmeal Stout… it is one of favorite styles. I jumped all over this Barney Flats Oatmeal Stout, by Anderson Valley Brewing Company when I saw it. My first sampling came late at night, the kids were asleep, and my wife and I sat on the porch to read our books and listen to the ocean.
The beer poured very nice and thick with a very small, brown head. It smelled wonderfully roasty, with hops hidden very, very, far in the background. My first sip took me back a bit. It was strong all around, but the roasted malt aroma carried through to the taste too strong for my tastes and was less carmel/chocolate like and more French roasted coffee like. It was thick and creamy, like an oatmeal should be.
Overall, I liked this beer a lot, but not until after I changed my mindset. You see, I was expecting (or maybe just hoping) for an oatmeal stout like the one I used to be able to get from my local brew pub before the brew master left with the recipe. Though they tried, the pub was never able to duplicate it. That Oatmeal Stout was also thick and smooth, but so well rounded and wet it immediately became one of my all time favorite beers.
The Barney Flats Oatmeal Stout was a little too sharp for my tastes. Again, I came around to liking it more for what is really was, instead of what I was hoping it to be. It is a fantastic night cap beer and actually was perfect in the current atmosphere I was in. It could compliment a dessert, but more likely it IS the dessert. Come to think of it, it might also make a good breakfast. As a matter of fact, as they say, “It’s not just shy sluggin gorms neemer.” (I’ll leave that up to you to figure out – post a comment if you do)
Hats off to Anderson Valley Brewing Company for making a great beer in a style that not many try to attempt. I look forward to trying the rest of their collection.