Brooklyn Brewery Monster Ale Revisited

I have taken a few timid steps toward cellaring some of my beer. Last January I had some Brooklyn Monster Ale and very specifically put aside a bottle to have…oh, about now. It’s been an awful temptation to see it back for just about all of 2009. This is a bottle from 2008.

Very pretty caramel color and clear. What little head it has falls fairly quickly. There’s some vanilla in the aroma, plus a bit of floral, but mostly it’s significantly malty/bready. It’s thick. Not syrupy, but obviously very high gravity. Big malty flavor with a little bit of heat from the alcohol.

Question is: Is it better than it was a year ago?

I say yes. Most of the “harshness” I found in it last January has certainly mellowed. It’s warm and complex. It’s good. Should I cellar it for longer? I don’t know, but it would be hard to leave it alone for that long.

Monster Barleywine

Brooklyn Brewery Monster Ale

Brooklyn Brewery Monster Ale 2008 - photo copyright Naomi EverettBeer-a-Day #3

I guess it’s Barley Wine week.

I’ve never had this before, in spite of being a big Brooklyn Brewery fan.

Nice medium-brown color with some slight red highlights. Off-white head that settles into about an eighth of an inch of foam. Bready with a bit of floral spice. Flavor is biscuity and a little harsh, though not unpleasantly so. This one seem like it could do with some time to mellow. I have another bottle that I’ll save at least halfway through the year, but I’ll try to hold off until the end of ’09.

Brooklyn Brewery Monster Ale